Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Fernando Ferreira Jr's avatar

This idea of law as the law of the strongest, or, in other words, the pure and simple existence of the law of the strongest, which unfortunately, but understandably, has gained ground in some sectors of the New Right, is a distant echo of the eternal debate between Socrates and Thrasymachus in the first pages of The Republic. It is a temptation that befalls us all, especially us jurists and lawyers: in the face of prevailing disorder and injustice, to let ourselves be taken over by the spirit of the times and become cynical like Thrasymachus. We must always be on guard against this temptation, even though we can well understand the reasons that lead people to mistakenly disbelieve in the inherent reality of law and justice. Thank you very much for the timely reminder, professor.

Expand full comment
As the Cedars's avatar

Fantastic and well-articulated, Professor!

There might be a small typo: “or that or that (negative) liberty“ … unless, this is appearing only on my device.

-Dody (we met once when I was an undergrad at Harvard and you spoke to the Catholic Student Association)

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts