Discussion about this post

User's avatar
TheAbjectLesson's avatar

This is fascinating. Thank you, Prof. V.

Many years ago, I had started working on a kernel of a (legal writing) idea on the subject of judicial review, after reading Dworkin's "Law's Empire" not too long after law school. I remember my working title was "A Preference for Liberty," but recall very little of the substantive content. This runs somewhat alongside it, I would say, and it's nice to know that my uneducated blobs of thought at least manage to have a kernel in common with some great legal minds of the past.

Sally Wong's avatar

Thanks as always for your illuminating articles, Prof. I have nothing to add except to note Footnote 1 not only adds to the strength of your thesis, it also demonstrates how in real situations in real life, judges must face the difficult outliers statutes cannot cover: "Any and all errors, em-dashes and overdrawn antitheses are my own, rather than a product of 'that hideous strength', an ‘Artificial “Intelligence’.” Judges need to face the difficult outliers. If they don’t, who will?

I also note the distinction Portalis' made of civil matters v. criminal matters.

6 more comments...

Ready for more?