If the constitution was instituted by liberals, and we are entering post-liberalism as a reaction to its excesses, is it unreasonable to think that post-constitutionalism is next? Or is constitutionalism not inherently liberal?
Yes, I was implying that our constitution was inherently liberal but not necessarily constitutionalism itself, there have been many illiberal constitutions. I will grant that any liberalism of the founders was at least not what we would consider today as “liberal” in any meaningful sense. I don’t think many self-identifying liberals would agree with the signers of the constitution on anything of importance.
But the point that I didn’t make very well was that since the liberals of today have back written the constitution in order to justify their liberal interpretation of it and conservatives of today seem to be totally inept at using their constitutional power to conserve anything, much less at least prevent liberals from rendering it meaningless, are we not effectively post-constitutional or on our way to post-constitutionalism?
We can all readily admit that liberalism was dead on arrival; that any merits it has are just snippets of a more coherent political order. But it seems that any appeals to the constitution on the left or right are as baseless as appeals to our monetary system - it works because we all have confidence in it and it is backed by the use of force. So, we submit to it. Or at least the idea of it.
I’m not trying to make a cute argument about how everything is fake and just be cynical. The dollar still buys things, I still want to make money, and we have enforcement of our laws. But the constitution now seems to be the one myth that we argue about and while arguing about it’s interpretation can hold us over temporarily and lends legitimacy to it, there’s obviously an erosion that seems to be irreversible, except maybe through executive orders that don’t last past an administration. And it’s these executive orders that give credibility to each president since congress can’t do much, how are we not moving to a post-constitutional order that is no longer centered on the myth of the constitution but on the myth of the man? Which seems to have begun with Trump and his cult following.
If you have the time, I've heard accusations of the good Doctor laying the ground for legal positivism and would appreciate either being pointed in the direction showing this isn't true to study on my own, or an article I can point to so as to answer such accusations.
Like I said to Adrian - it was never something I looked into or was interested in pursuing, and seemed to be a silly accusation. Him being elevated to a Dr changes that choice.
It also could be that the people were getting St Thomas More confused with him. I don’t know.
I agree, it sounds to me like a silly accusation at best, or even a bad faith argument to undermine his achievements and thought. If you encounter any more of these in the wild, I’d be very interested in seeing what they say.
Sure thing. It's been likely a year since I heard it last, but accusations against Saints tend to increase the more they're elevated, so it's likely to come up again.
I have, but from those that I suspect of either a lack of understanding/nuance, or who are forming their opinions from hearsay. I haven't read his writings enough to have offered an opinion or refute it without possibly making a fool of myself and the matter worse through ignorance
Matthew Levering has a decent book out on Newman and the difference between corruption and development. I wonder if Newman read Maistre on the importance of institutional development in Generative Principles.
If the constitution was instituted by liberals, and we are entering post-liberalism as a reaction to its excesses, is it unreasonable to think that post-constitutionalism is next? Or is constitutionalism not inherently liberal?
This doesn’t even make sense what
Thank you for the reply.
Yes, I was implying that our constitution was inherently liberal but not necessarily constitutionalism itself, there have been many illiberal constitutions. I will grant that any liberalism of the founders was at least not what we would consider today as “liberal” in any meaningful sense. I don’t think many self-identifying liberals would agree with the signers of the constitution on anything of importance.
But the point that I didn’t make very well was that since the liberals of today have back written the constitution in order to justify their liberal interpretation of it and conservatives of today seem to be totally inept at using their constitutional power to conserve anything, much less at least prevent liberals from rendering it meaningless, are we not effectively post-constitutional or on our way to post-constitutionalism?
We can all readily admit that liberalism was dead on arrival; that any merits it has are just snippets of a more coherent political order. But it seems that any appeals to the constitution on the left or right are as baseless as appeals to our monetary system - it works because we all have confidence in it and it is backed by the use of force. So, we submit to it. Or at least the idea of it.
I’m not trying to make a cute argument about how everything is fake and just be cynical. The dollar still buys things, I still want to make money, and we have enforcement of our laws. But the constitution now seems to be the one myth that we argue about and while arguing about it’s interpretation can hold us over temporarily and lends legitimacy to it, there’s obviously an erosion that seems to be irreversible, except maybe through executive orders that don’t last past an administration. And it’s these executive orders that give credibility to each president since congress can’t do much, how are we not moving to a post-constitutional order that is no longer centered on the myth of the constitution but on the myth of the man? Which seems to have begun with Trump and his cult following.
If you have the time, I've heard accusations of the good Doctor laying the ground for legal positivism and would appreciate either being pointed in the direction showing this isn't true to study on my own, or an article I can point to so as to answer such accusations.
That would greatly surprise me, given that legal positivism predates Newman by around a century.
Like I said to Adrian - it was never something I looked into or was interested in pursuing, and seemed to be a silly accusation. Him being elevated to a Dr changes that choice.
It also could be that the people were getting St Thomas More confused with him. I don’t know.
I agree, it sounds to me like a silly accusation at best, or even a bad faith argument to undermine his achievements and thought. If you encounter any more of these in the wild, I’d be very interested in seeing what they say.
Sure thing. It's been likely a year since I heard it last, but accusations against Saints tend to increase the more they're elevated, so it's likely to come up again.
I have, but from those that I suspect of either a lack of understanding/nuance, or who are forming their opinions from hearsay. I haven't read his writings enough to have offered an opinion or refute it without possibly making a fool of myself and the matter worse through ignorance
Matthew Levering has a decent book out on Newman and the difference between corruption and development. I wonder if Newman read Maistre on the importance of institutional development in Generative Principles.